CPG Hiring Strategies That Protect Your Margins

CPG hiring strategies from recruiters who staff brand, sales and supply chain teams. See what works in 2026 with advice from MSH.

Tomas Layrisse
Oct 21, 2026
# mins
CPG Hiring Strategies That Protect Your Margins

CPG Hiring Strategies That Protect Your Margins

CPG hiring strategies from recruiters who staff brand, sales and supply chain teams. See what works in 2026 with advice from MSH.

CPG Hiring Strategies That Protect Your Margins

CPG hiring strategies from recruiters who staff brand, sales and supply chain teams. See what works in 2026 with advice from MSH.

A 2025 study from PMMI, The Association for Packaging and Processing Technologies, found that 95% of end users, a group that includes consumer packaged goods (CPG) companies, struggle to find skilled operators and technicians.

That makes CPG hiring strategies matter more than ever. CPG companies run on thin profit margins, so there's little financial cushion to absorb the cost of a bad hire.

CPG recruitment specialists also see challenges behind the skills gap. Companies swing between centralizing and decentralizing their talent acquisition strategies.

Regional brands that once operated independently now face pressure to align with global hiring practices without losing local flexibility.

To unpack this, we've turned to Tomas Layrisse, VP of Solutions, Global RPO at MSH, who brings a practical perspective on what works in hiring and what doesn't. In his experience, talent acquisition has reached an inflection point.

The biggest misconception among CPG brands is treating talent acquisition like just another line item on the P&L, something that lives only within HR. Tomas puts it bluntly.

“They treat HR like a cost center. No, you are the talent expert. I’m the marketer. Let's work together on messaging, branding, attraction, and selection.”

In Tomas's experience, talent acquisition is a pillar of growth. So companies must rethink how recruitment fits into their broader strategy, not as a support function but as a core driver of business performance.

Here’s what that foundational shift looks like in practice.

The Three Roles CPG Companies Struggle Most To Fill

Growth depends on filling the right roles, and three give CPG companies the most trouble right now. Brand and category management is one. Revenue and field sales is another, and supply chain and operations is the third. Each is hard to fill for a different reason.

Brand And Category Management

Brand and category managers are your brand's strategic storytellers and the data-driven people who turn retail scanner data into business intelligence you can act on. That mix of creative breadth and analytical depth is what makes the role so hard to fill.

A brand manager search, for example, means finding candidates who pair advanced IT and data skills with deep category and market knowledge. According to ManpowerGroup's 2025 consumer goods outlook, 73% of consumer goods employers worldwide are struggling to find the skilled talent they need.

Revenue And Field Sales

When you're building out a multi-state field sales team, you need people with deep CPG category expertise, proven revenue generation, technical fluency and the communication skills to work with different corporate teams.

Candidates with this combination are rare. In the same ManpowerGroup report, sales and marketing tops the list of skills consumer goods employers find hardest to source, at 29%. With a pool that small, a bad hiring process can cost you the candidates you want. As Tomas points out, “About 53% of candidates share their negative hiring experiences online. If your process is slow, unclear, or frustrating, you’re harming your brand.”

Supply Chain And Operations

CPG supply chain and operations talent makes sure your products reach shelves with minimal risk. When you need to staff a new plant quickly, these are the roles that keep production and shipping moving.

Demand for newer CPG categories, like functional beverages, sustainable food, beauty and wellness, is changing what you need on the floor. These roles call for people who understand traditional CPG operations and supply chain uncertainty, plus the IT and data skills to run the equipment. Keeping these workers is just as hard. In PMMI's 2025 Inside the Workforce Gap report, 72% of end users report high turnover among line operators.

What To Centralize And What To Leave To Each Region

How you organize hiring for these roles also matters. There is no perfect playbook for whether CPG companies should fully centralize or decentralize their talent acquisition functions.

According to Tomas, organizations frequently shift between the two models. “We helped a $4 billion food manufacturing company navigate the journey from decentralized to centralized and back again. Now, they’re centralizing once more,” Tomas explains.

These frequent shifts point to a deeper issue. The real challenge isn't choosing a perfect organizational structure. It’s achieving internal alignment. Without alignment, Tomas warns, any model becomes “a recipe for failure.”

Decisions to centralize or decentralize must come from the very top of the organization. “HR and TA cannot lead strategic shifts alone,” Tomas says. “It has to come from the CEO or president level.”

Announcing the decision isn’t enough, though. “You can gather everyone in a room and shout directives, but that won’t hold for long. You need a real change management strategy with accountability and clear metrics,” Tomas says.

The fix is a structured accountability framework set by executive leadership. Dashboards and technology can offer visibility, but lasting success depends on top-down alignment and disciplined execution.

Tomas insists effective alignment isn't about conformity or giving up local market insight. It’s about shared goals, consistent measurement and strong accountability. “Leadership strategy is corporate level,” he says. “Local execution can still adapt to specific market conditions, but everyone needs to measure success the same way.”

Hiring Metrics That Get CFOs And CEOs To Say Yes

Once leadership is aligned, keeping executives bought in means speaking in business outcomes rather than recruitment jargon. “You can't just talk about cost per hire. You need metrics that executives care about, metrics that drive decisions,” Tomas says.

Start with the presented-to-hire ratio, which shows executives both efficiency and quality. “About 38% of the candidates we present get hired. That’s not just about efficiency, it’s about quality,” Tomas notes.

Revenue per employee is another critical metric because it ties hiring quality to the bottom line. “We were the RPO partner for Restaurant Brands International for seven years, and during that time their stock quadrupled,” Tomas shares. “Revenue per employee went up significantly because the quality of hires improved.”

Tomas also encourages leaders to look past traditional recruitment metrics and adopt “Quality per Cost,” a more strategic measure of hiring success. It moves beyond simply cutting expenses to getting the most talent quality for the money you invest.

When To Measure Success

When you measure matters as much as what you measure. Tomas recommends setting 30, 60, 90 and 180-day goals so both employee and employer can measure success concretely.

“We measure hiring success not at the hire date, but 180 days after,” Tomas says. “Did the employee achieve the goals set during hiring? That’s when we know we've succeeded.”

That 180-day mark is also when a bad hire gets expensive. If a brand manager turns out to be the wrong fit at six months, you’ve already spent more than $27,000 in salary, based on the $55,500 low end of the typical CPG brand manager salary range.

Replacing that person can cost another 50% to 200% of their annual salary, according to Gallup. For a brand with a product launch on the calendar, it also means six months of lost momentum.

Speed belongs on the scorecard too. “Candidates today should go from application to interview within two days or less,” Tomas states plainly. Text-to-apply options, mobile-first applications and instant scheduling bots make that target realistic, and they raise candidate satisfaction along the way.

Together, the presented-to-hire ratio, 180-day success, revenue per employee and time to interview show the strategic value of talent acquisition. They secure executive buy-in and keep the focus on hiring quality people.

How To Keep Quality High When Hiring At Scale

Those metrics face their toughest test when hiring volume jumps. High-volume hiring in CPG is notoriously difficult, and consistency is usually the first thing to slip. “Everyone can stuff the funnel, but filtering effectively to ensure culture fit and quality is the real challenge,” Tomas says.

Seasonal hiring spikes, plant openings and field sales expansions all require companies to screen and hire large numbers of candidates quickly. But scaling well takes more than filling roles fast.

Hiring the wrong candidates racks up extra costs in rehiring and retraining. Productivity suffers while roles stay open, and a rushed or frustrating process damages your employer brand.

A Structured, Proactive Approach

To manage volume, Tomas recommends a structured, proactive approach. His team at MSH uses a “24.5 sourcing model,” where recruiters continuously build and maintain strong talent pipelines. That way, high-quality candidates are always available when demand spikes, instead of the team relying on reactive job postings.

Structured interviews keep that filter consistent. “With structured interviews, every interviewer knows exactly what they’re evaluating, whether it’s culture, skill, leadership potential, or future growth,” Tomas says.

Hiring managers can make or break the timeline. “Recruiting is a 50/50 effort,” Tomas says. “Our team can deliver the best candidates available, but without prompt feedback from hiring managers, the process stalls and good candidates slip away.” His rule of thumb is simple. “Review candidates within 24 hours and provide feedback within 48 hours.”

So when does it make sense to keep high-volume hiring in-house? If you have a talent pool on hand and the resources to coordinate hiring logistics well, handling it internally can work. For many CPG companies, though, tight timelines, limited staff and budget make it smarter to partner with one of the top CPG recruitment firms for faster access to vetted talent that fits your team.

Where QSR Hiring Is Different

Many of the same principles apply to quick-service restaurant (QSR) hiring, but the priorities are different. CPG companies focus on the efficiency, safety and volume of what the factory produces, so frontline leadership sits at the plant level. QSR brands optimize for customer service, speed and local sales, so leadership sits at the unit level, in each restaurant or franchise location.

Franchise structures add another layer. Many QSR brands take a federated approach, where independent business owners call the shots locally, including on hiring. In return, each franchise owner pays for and receives an operating blueprint, supply chain access, brand assets and training support.

Speed and scale matter most for QSR brands when they open a new restaurant, which needs a full crew and trained managers in place before opening day. Fast crew hiring only works when the right leaders are in place to onboard staff in hours or days and keep key talent. That’s why QSR executive recruitment needs a strong slate of leaders who fit the culture and deeply understand the brand.

Your Talent Acquisition Team Is A Growth Engine

Tight margins leave little room for a bad hire, and the CPG talent shortage isn’t easing. The companies that come out ahead treat talent acquisition as “a foundational pillar of business growth,” in Tomas’s words. They align hiring from the top, measure it in business outcomes and build pipelines before demand spikes.

If you’re planning your next brand, sales or supply chain hiring push, see how MSH staffs CPG teams. The approach draws on 15,000 hires across 43 countries, and this CPG case study shows what it delivers in practice.

Love the hires you make

We manage the process to build your team. Your dedicated process manager will build you a sustainable team with great talent.

More about scaling your team

Digital Transformation

Data Quality vs. Data Integrity: Key Concepts and Distinctions

Decipher the excellence of data with our guide. Learn the crucial distinctions between data quality and integrity, ensuring your data management strategy excels in precision and reliability.

Employee Experience

How To Create The Ideal IT/Technology Team Structure

Craft the ideal IT team structure with MSH's expert guidance. Our insights go beyond theory, providing practical strategies to optimize your technology team for peak performance.

Podcast: Brad Wilson — Why Toxic Workplaces Don’t Deserve Your Loyalty

We’re joined by Brad Wilson, Senior HR Leader, Speaker, and Author of “Good Works.” Brad shares why culture must be built around kindness and purpose — not control — and how leaders can make (or break) engagement at scale.

Get A Consultation
Somebody will be in touch with you within the next 24 hours.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.